With one of the biggest reality shows on television,
the Pawn Stars crew has struck pawn shop paydirt
more times than even they can count.
But not every deal they make on the show is
a perfect play, and when they get ripped off,
they get ripped off big time.
Here are the worst moments when the Pawn Stars
got seriously cheated.
Shoeless Joe Jackson fake
In the season six episode “Say It Ain’t So,”
Rick shelled out $13,000 on a book he believed
might contain the authentic signature of baseball
great “Shoeless” Joe Jackson.
Rick couldn’t have been more excited during
“Do you know how rare it is to find his signature?”
“No, not at all.”
“It’s the rarest sports signature, period.”
But despite the seller’s questionable certificate
of authenticity, and Rick’s own reservations…
“Of all the signatures in the world this is
the most faked.”
…he took a gamble and bought it anyway.
After shelling out the cash, Rebecca, his
book expert, told him that the signature was
likely a fake.
So Rick then sent it out to another authenticator
who reiterated the bad news: not only was
it a forgery, it was a laughably bad one.
So much for that home run, Rick.
Willie Mays strike-out
In a 2012 episode, Corey made the blunder
of forking over $31,000 for what he believed
was a game-worn Willie Mays San Francisco
Giants uniform from 1961.
But the red flags with this one were apparent
from the jump.
For starters, the uniform was pristine—which
Chumlee noticed right away:
“This doesn’t look game-worn.
Willie Mays was a badass, he was sliding around
on the dirt and the grass.
I’d imagine there’d be a bunch of stains on
Good observation, Chum.
Also, the seller had no authentication paperwork
whatsoever, which is never a good sign.
But Big Hoss took a gamble and boy, was he
all kinds of wrong.
Not only did Gold & Silver Pawn fail to retail
it at a ridiculous asking price of $80,000,
but they only ended up getting only $19,200
for it at auction around two years later,
a nearly $12,000 loss.
And it gets worse.
Hauls of Shame reported that the uniform was
never worn in a game by Mays, because it never
even belonged to Mays.
That technically means Corey didn’t get as
ripped off as he could have, but we seriously
doubt he’s happy with how that deal went down.
“School’s in session.
You just got schooled.”
Wells Fargo heist
In a fifth season episode called “Corey’s
Big Play,” Rick made the unusual mistake of
buying something he was unsure of: a 19th-century
Wells Fargo strongbox containing an old prison
ball and chain.
And “unsure” is putting it lightly.
“Ok, What are you trying to say?”
He still dropped $450 on the box, only to
have his hopes of a profit shot down by expert
and show regular Mark “The Beard of Knowledge”
“This is a complete fantasy piece.
It’s a complete fake.”
Leave it up to the Old Man to rub it in.
If the World Famous Gold and Silver Pawn Shop
can’t retail an item, they always have the
option of sending it to auction.
That’s what Rick tried to do with several
big ticket items including a 1940s Indian
Motorcycle with a sidecar and a Vic Flick
owned and played Fender Stratocaster, which
he put on the block at Julien’s Auctions in
Unfortunately, he took a hit for “$29,000
on the motorcycle, and $35,000 on the guitar.”
He must not have done well with his other
items either, because he reported his total
loss at around $100,000.
“Sold most of my items, I’m getting my ass
handed to me.
Ahh, it doesn’t feel good.”
Blindsided by the bayou
When the History Channel launched Cajun Pawn
Stars in 2012, the boys from Las Vegas apparently
felt blindsided by the move.
According to TMZ, the network had promised
no spin-offs would be produced.
The History Channel called the new addition
a “southern spin” on the original, and they
“I got some gator, I got some raccoon.
Which one we gonna cook?”
Neither the network nor the Harrisons commented
publicly on the tension, but former Pawn Stars
manager Wayne Jefferies said he was the mole
that talked to TMZ, and he said he got fired
Looks like in this case, Pawn Stars didn’t
get ripped off by a customer — they got
ripped off by their own network.
“See ya later, dork.”
Thanks for watching!
Click the Looper icon to subscribe to our
Plus check out all this cool stuff we know
you’ll love, too!